Supporting materials and pattern evidence for the United States’ Title VII challenge to Minnesota’s race- and sex-based affirmative action regime, and related race-conscious education employment and grant practices

MEMORANDUM

To:

Civil Rights Division, U.S. Department of Justice

Employment Litigation Section

Attorneys handling United States v. State of Minnesota, No. 0:26-cv-00273 (D. Minn.)

From:

Phillip C. Parrish

Retired U.S. Navy Lieutenant Commander (Intelligence)

Fraud whistleblower; lifelong Minnesota resident, farmer, father, and Parish Executive Administrator

Date: August 26, 2026

Re: Supporting materials and pattern evidence for the United States’ Title VII challenge to Minnesota’s race- and sex-based affirmative action regime, and related race-conscious education employment and grant practices

I. Interest of the Submitter

I submit this memorandum as a Minnesota citizen, parent, former naval intelligence officer, and candidate who has spent years documenting organized fraud and systemic failures under the current state administration. The facts below are drawn from public records, official Minnesota Department of Education (MDE) announcements, court filings, and contemporaneous reporting. They demonstrate that Minnesota’s affirmative action mandates are not isolated personnel rules—they form part of a deliberate, race-sorted education policy apparatus that treats groups as differentially capable, produces measurable academic harm, and coexists with large-scale fraud.

This information is offered to assist the United States in developing the factual record, discovery requests, and pattern-or-practice evidence in United States v. State of Minnesota.

II. The Core Legal Issue in Context

The United States correctly alleges that Minnesota Statutes §§ 43A.19 and 43A.191, and implementing rules, require state agencies to maintain race- and sex-based affirmative action plans and to consider affirmative action goals in “all staffing and personnel decisions.” This is a facial command to classify and prefer on the basis of race and sex in employment—exactly the practice Title VII prohibits.

That same mindset governs Minnesota’s K-12 and higher-education workforce policies under Governor Walz’s “Due North” Education Plan (launched 2021) and its ongoing implementation. Due North explicitly prioritizes recruiting, retaining, and supporting “teachers of color and Indigenous teachers.” Recent MDE actions continue that directive:

• On August 18, 2026, MDE announced more than $41 million in grants through the Educator Workforce and Development Center. The awards are framed as a core Walz-Flanagan initiative and include substantial funding for Grow Your Own (Adult and Student Pathways), Educator Tuition Assistance (formerly CUGMEC), Special Education Teacher Pathway, Teacher Mentorship and Retention (with priority for teachers of color and American Indian teachers), and Teacher Residency/Apprenticeship programs. Multiple program descriptions and statutory language prioritize candidates and teachers by race.

• Grow Your Own and related programs report high percentages of participants of color (e.g., 83% in one adult-pathway cohort) and impose spending requirements that favor those categories.

• Mentorship and retention grants expressly prioritize programs for teachers of color or American Indian teachers and, in some cases, require negotiation of additional retention protections for those groups.

These are not race-neutral efforts to expand the overall teacher supply. They are race-conscious classification and preference systems operated by state agencies and funded with public money.

III. Judicial Recognition of the Discriminatory Character

In the related case against Minneapolis Public Schools (MPS) concerning collective-bargaining provisions that give “underrepresented” (BIPOC) teachers preferential protection from seniority-based layoffs and reassignments (and special treatment for Black Men Teach Fellows), Chief Judge Patrick Schiltz dismissed the Department’s complaint without prejudice on August 10, 2026, solely on procedural grounds (necessary-party issues involving the union). Critically, the court stated it harbors “grave doubts about the legality of the racial discrimination in which MPS is forced to engage” and noted that MPS does not deny the contract requires discrimination by race.

The same logic applies statewide. Treating groups as differentially entitled to employment protections or pipeline funding is the precise classification Title VII forbids. The premise underlying these programs—that certain racial groups are less capable of competing on equal terms without permanent racial engineering—is itself the discriminatory stereotype the statute targets.

IV. Measurable Academic Harm: The Outcomes the Policies Claim to Improve

Despite years of Due North priorities, race-weighted grants, and equity centers, Minnesota student outcomes remain poor and have not closed the gaps the policies purport to address:

• Minnesota Comprehensive Assessment (MCA) results continue to show majorities of students not proficient in reading and mathematics (approximately 45–50% proficient range in recent years).

• National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) scores have declined relative to pre-2019 peaks; fourth-grade reading has at times fallen below the national average.

• Racial achievement gaps persist.

The state continues to celebrate graduation rates while basic skills stagnate. The race-preference apparatus has not produced the promised academic recovery. Instead, it has institutionalized the view that equal treatment is insufficient and that differential treatment by race is required.

V. Concurrent Large-Scale Fraud in the Education System

While race-sorted teacher pipelines receive tens of millions, Minnesota’s higher-education system has been unable to prevent industrial-scale identity-theft fraud known as “ghost students.”

• At Normandale Community College (Minnesota’s largest community college), administrators report having processed approximately 29,000 fraudulent or potentially fraudulent applications. The current rate of potentially fraudulent applications is approximately 31% (previously as high as 42%).

• The Minnesota State system has flagged thousands of additional suspicious financial-aid applications across its campuses. Federal authorities previously identified roughly 1,834 ghost students in Minnesota associated with approximately $12.5 million in aid.

• Real victims suffer identity theft, damaged credit, and unpaid loans taken out in their names. Institutions face potential repayment liability to the federal government.

This fraud occurs under the same administration that prioritizes race-conscious workforce engineering over basic competence, verification, and accountability. The coexistence of elaborate racial preferences with systemic inability to verify student identity is evidence of misplaced institutional priorities and weak controls—facts relevant to evaluating the good-faith (or lack thereof) of Minnesota’s claimed remedial justifications.

VI. Pattern Evidence for the Court’s Consideration

The following facts form a coherent pattern that supports the United States’ claim of a statewide employment practice of race and sex classification:

1. Statutory and regulatory mandates requiring race/sex affirmative action plans and consideration of AA goals in all staffing decisions (the core of the present case).

2. Parallel race-prioritized grant and pipeline programs in K-12 teacher recruitment, preparation, mentorship, and retention under Due North and the Educator Workforce and Development Center.

3. Explicit contractual race preferences in the largest urban district (MPS), which a federal judge has already characterized as raising grave doubts of legality.

4. Persistent academic underperformance and unclosed gaps despite years of race-focused intervention.

5. Concurrent large-scale fraud in the postsecondary system that the same governance structure has failed to prevent.

Taken together, these demonstrate that Minnesota does not merely maintain a discrete civil-service AA program. It operates a coordinated, race-conscious education employment regime whose premise is that equal treatment is inadequate and that racial classification is necessary and perpetual. That premise is the definition of the discrimination Title VII was enacted to end.

VII. Recommendations for the Ongoing Litigation

1. Discovery – Seek documents and testimony concerning the design, implementation, metrics, and outcomes of Due North teacher-diversity programs, Grow Your Own, CUGMEC/ETAP, mentorship grants, and any race-weighted spending requirements. Request internal analyses of whether these programs have improved student proficiency or closed gaps.

2. Expert evidence – Develop testimony on the academic and constitutional costs of treating groups as differentially capable, and on the empirical failure of race-preference pipelines to produce measurable student gains.

3. Pattern supplementation – Use the MPS “grave doubts” language and the Normandale fraud data as circumstantial evidence of institutional mindset and of the practical consequences of prioritizing identity classification over competence and integrity.

4. Related enforcement – Consider parallel Title VI or False Claims Act scrutiny of any remaining race-restricted education grants still receiving federal funds.

VIII. Conclusion

Minnesota’s affirmative action regime and its parallel education workforce policies rest on the same discriminatory premise: that certain groups are less capable and therefore require permanent racial engineering. That premise is both false and unlawful under Title VII. The academic results, the judicial observations in the MPS case, and the concurrent fraud epidemic provide powerful factual support for the United States’ position.

I stand ready to provide additional documentation, affidavits, or testimony as needed. Minnesota’s children—of every background—deserve schools and employment systems grounded in equal protection and measurable competence, not race checkboxes and institutional gaslighting.

Respectfully submitted,

Phillip C. Parrish

phillip@parrish4mn.com

(612) 460-1717