This is not a surprise. It is not a bad year. It is not “just politics.” It is a perennial operation: cause the pain, wait until the origin fades, then coerce the public with the symptom. Minnesota families are paying more for electricity, natural gas, gasoline, and diesel at the same moment cost of living is the top issue on the ballot. That timing is the product. The people who wrote the mandates, indexed the fuel tax, and signed off on utility profit bumps needed the invoice. An unaware citizen who does not remember the statute will blame whoever is standing in front of the pump in October. That is the design.
Call it what it is. This is Munchausen by proxy as governance. The caregiver makes the child sick, rushes in as the hero, and harvests sympathy, money, and control. The DFL/DSA machine and its bureaucrats induce the cost—carbon-free-by-2040 deadlines, indexed motor-fuel taxes, Clean Cars rules, PUC votes that raise authorized utility profits—then appear on camera as the only people who “care” that you cannot fill the tank. They did not fail to prevent the harm. The harm is the inventory. Pleasure and profit for the enterprise: offices, appointments, nonprofit pipelines, rate-base returns, campaign narrative. The citizen is the patient who is never allowed to get well, because wellness would end the show.
Xcel asked for a two-year electric increase of $490.7 million. The Public Utilities Commission cut the headline number and still raised the company’s authorized return on equity from 9.25 percent to 9.6 percent—tens of millions a year extra for shareholders while more than 8,600 public comments said no. Gas rate cases followed the same path. At the pump, regular gasoline in Minnesota is about $4.37 a gallon. A year ago it was roughly $2.99. Diesel just set an all-time state record near $6.33. The DFL majority indexed the state motor-fuel tax so it climbs without another hard vote: 28.5 cents through 2024, 31.8 cents in 2025, 32.6 cents in 2026. Stack the federal excise on top and the government take is already more than half a dollar a gallon. Then they imported California-style Clean Cars rules that treated ordinary trucks as a moral defect. After lawsuits the state moved to withdraw the mandate. The cause was already in the code. The effect is on your statement. The memory hole is the campaign.
Now watch the faces they put on the lie—the same names, every cycle, because the enterprise does not improvise. It repeats.
Amy Klobuchar does not mention the 2023 carbon-free electricity law. She does not mention the indexed gas tax her party locked in. She does not mention the PUC vote that padded authorized utility profit. She posts that “Trump’s war with Iran continues to cause gas prices to skyrocket,” cites $4.40 gasoline and record diesel, and uses it to attack a Republican gubernatorial candidate. Another post: President Trump calls higher prices “a very inexpensive price to pay” for the war—“Tell that to the Minnesotans paying $4.38 for gas, and over $6.30 for diesel.” In May she blamed “the Administration’s policies,” tariffs, and Iran, then pivoted to year-round E-15 as if a blend waiver erases a state tax table. Last winter she tried to pin surging electricity prices and past-due utility balances on Trump; the chart she used measured balances that were already climbing before he took office. She is counting on you not remembering who wrote the Minnesota line items. The media repeats the pump number. It almost never prints the statute she skips. That is not a reporting accident. That is the amplifier.
Keith Ellison is the textbook proxy move. His office files to reconsider the Xcel return-on-equity hike and gets covered as the consumer’s last defender—the parent who “saved” the child after the household made the child sick. Then he turns around and says, in his own April 2026 press release, that “Trump’s war with Iran has driven up gas prices across the nation” while he fights to keep federal money flowing into “clean and affordable energy” programs. He sued oil companies for climate deception. He does not sue the legislature that wrote the mandate utilities cite when they file for hundreds of millions more. The Star Tribune and MPR frame the ROE petition as affordability courage. They do not ask why the same political family spent years treating hydrocarbons as the villain and then acts stunned when the bill arrives. Look like you fought the utility. Keep the climate narrative. Blame Washington. Collect the credit. That is the racket.
Peggy Flanagan was lieutenant governor while those energy laws and tax indexes were the administration’s product. Now she runs for Senate on the claim that Donald Trump “has cost our state far too much already,” that an “illegal war” is driving gas and fertilizer prices, and that Minnesotans who “stop the pump at $10” need a senator who would not have supported it. She tells the story of a single mom stretching $20. The story is meant to hurt. What she does not tell is that her own ticket signed the carbon-free deadline, backed the transportation package that indexed the fuel tax, and spent years selling “transition” as compassion. The war can move crude. It did not invent Minnesota’s tax schedule or the PUC docket. Using a working mother’s tank as a campaign prop while skipping the laws you helped govern is not empathy. It is the proxy parent describing the fever she helped induce.
Steve Simon does not write energy policy. He runs elections. That is the point. Affordability is the top issue. Gas prices are a documented vote-mover. Two-thirds of voters in national polling say pump prices influence how they vote. The same media that interviews Simon about ballots and “protecting elections” almost never connects the DFL energy statutes to the envelope and the pump that will walk into the polling place with the voter. The Secretary of State’s office is the quiet end of the assembly line: the bills get raised, the origin is forgotten, the narrative is aimed at Trump, the coverage stays on process, and the people who wrote the cost never have to defend it on the same stage as the people who administer the contest. The enterprise does not need Simon to lie about gasoline. It needs the public too exhausted and too short-memoried to ask who started the fire.
Think about what is actually happening. These are not confused public servants who “missed” the downstream effects. They are operators in a criminal enterprise that uses harm to citizens as working capital. Cause and effect are planned years ahead: pass the mandate in a “climate leadership” session; let the utility file; let the tax index click up every January; wait until no one can quote the bill number; then flood the airwaves with Iran, tariffs, and Trump. Coerce the unaware. Shame the farmer who needs diesel. Shame the veteran on a fixed income. Shame the mother who stops the pump at ten dollars. Then offer yourself as the only adult in the room. That is not governance. That is a syndicate that has discovered pain is cheaper than persuasion and more reliable than truth.
A constitutional republic does not treat a heating bill or a tank of diesel as a prop, and it does not treat families as patients to be kept sick for the practitioner’s pleasure. Reliable, affordable energy is what lets a farmer finish harvest, a parish keep the school warm, and a father keep his job without choosing between fuel and food. Minnesota can have that. It requires remembering the origin—naming the statute, the tax table, the PUC order, and the officials who still cash the narrative—ending the fantasy deadlines, stopping automatic tax escalators, putting nuclear and natural gas back on the table, and forcing every rate case and fuel levy to answer one question: does this serve the people who pay it, or the enterprise that needs their pain to stay in power?
The dockets are public. The tax table is public. Their posts are public. AAA posts the pump price every morning. None of this is hidden. What they count on is that you will forget who made you sick long enough for them to sell you the cure. Refuse the amnesia. Name the origin. That is how the proxy ends.
Phillip C. Parrish
Heidi Wanty, Manager
(612) 460-1717